Corporation tax welcomed but only as a first step...
BUDGET day, and one of reckoning for business. The headlines:
: Corporation tax down from 30p to 28p - lowest of all major economies.
: Small companies tax rate from 20p to 22p from 2009.
: All companies to have £50,000 investment allowance.
: Science investment to rise to £6.3 billion.
: Capital allowances to be modernised.
Here two guest bloggers give their immediate thoughts.
Andrew Palmer, Confederation of British Industry deputy director for the Yorkshire and Humber: The CBI welcomes the cut in the headline rate of corporation tax.
By making this move the Chancellor has acknowledged the need for the UK to compete with the tax regimes in other developed countries in order to secure jobs and investment for the future.
In particular the change will benefit those big profitable companies that might otherwise be thinking of shifting their activities to lower tax regimes.
However the business sector as a whole will not be popping the champagne corks tonight. These changes will not initially reduce the overall burden of business taxes, and there will be losers as well as winners.
Some big companies that for one reason or another don’t pay much tax will lose out. So will small companies that don’t invest much, and so will not be able to benefit from the new capital allowances.
Companies will also be uneasy about Sir Michael Lyons’ proposals for a supplementary business rate. They will be very relieved that responsibility for business rates is not going to be returned to local authorities. But they will have to persuaded about the economic benefits that might come from a supplementary rate and they will need to be formally consulted on every proposal to ensure that their money will be well spent.
Overall, the Budget is only a first step on a journey that will need to go further. The challenge for government now is to get a grip on public spending so as to create the headroom that will be needed for further tax cuts in the years ahead.
Michael Izza, chief executvie of The Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales:
Yet again, the Chancellor has ignored the requests of business and of professionals. A 2% cut in corporation tax is a step forward, but should be implemented now not in 12 months. By failing to do something about our over-complicated tax system and with the other changes particularly for smaller businesses, the Chancellor has missed an opportunity to ease the regulatory burden. It’s therefore not surprising that many businesses across the country feel disengaged from the political process.
In its budget submission to HM Treasury, the ICAEW called for, amongst other things, a reduction in corporation tax and a formal commitment to tax simplification that will help improve the UK’s competitiveness within the global economy. The budget submission also urged Government to review how its skills policy is working with business and improve the tax credits for small business research & development.
“Whilst we welcome many of the specific measures that the chancellor has announced, it’s still a piecemeal budget which tinkers with the system rather than starting the comprehensive reform which is so overdue. The challenge for his successor will be to reform as much as to be prudent.